Surely the truth counts, even online

02/Mar/2010

Comments: 3 readers have left a comment

THE internet in Australia is fast becoming a defamation free-for-all, where all manner of absurd claims and untruths can be made without repercussion.

Take the few examples that have sprung up on social networking site Facebook here in Perth and on the east coast in recent days.

In Perth, a young man’s simple plan to raise awareness of anti-social behaviour at Midland was hijacked on Facebook by individuals posting racist pictures and offensive comments about Aborigines in the area.

Not surprisingly, most of the comments and attributions – cheap shots really – were made anonymously or through a series of bogus or fake Facebook accounts or identities.

In Queensland, a group dedicated to the memory of murdered eight-year-old Bundaberg girl Trinity Bates had their Facebook site vandalised by morons posting pornography and sexually explicit content on their memorial site.

Facebook administrators were slow in shutting down the offensive content, suggesting to me that they didn’t  care.

Adding more fuel to the fire, a Perth company won a public apology and was awarded $30,000 in damages in the WA Supreme Court last week after an anonymous blogger was found guilty of tarnishing the firm’s reputation.

The company’s win is historic – it ought to serve as a reminder that individuals can be held accountable for unfair or untrue defamatory imputations, even when made anonymously.

The controversy of the past week now has the Federal Government seriously contemplating the merits of an Internet Ombudsman to presumably adjudicate on complaints, and police those who publish online.

Web publishers are expected to act responsibly, but it is clear many do not. Not only do they need to act within the law, but they also ought to demonstrate  reasonable taste and common sense too – qualities often lacking in cyberspace.

Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Tim Swinden

14/06/2010

The basic premise of free speech is that the general reader is civilized and intelligent enough to discern crap from thought without some power from on high telling them what they can or can not read.

Now maybe given the general state of Australian society this is a fond hope, but still those who are really intelligent let others think them self so without the heavy and idiot hand moral censorship.

Arguments are won by reason, not by personal indignation.

Gerry Georgatos

08/03/2010

The internet is a facility and not an overwhelming entity in its own right. Mechanisms to keep it legitimate, independent and within paradigms were not pursued with any sophistication as it was opened up to citizen media and every sector of perceived commercial enterprise, and with disregard of international laws and conventions, those that keep us within sight of the dream that is civility.

The internet is not some entity in its own right, something Archimedean, it is a human construct very much dependent upon its human administrators even when as an 'automaton' it is geared to increasing programmed functions and a limited scope, which allows human beings engaging with it to get away with what ordinarily we would not want humans to do.

This is the time to ordain and enshrine rigour in what gets published and what should not be published, and in ensuring the mechanisms in place to ensure appropriate audit and check rather than people living in the implications of recklessness.

Austin May

02/03/2010

No-one can control the internet.

The net was designed to be an indestructible series of nodes in the wake of world war two. It's very design makes it impossible to control and impossible to take down altogether.

Likrewise Web Administrators can never be held acountable for what small parts they play in maintaining sites which other people post comments on. The cannot be omnipitent.

On the net "quality is relevance".
Search engines operate on the relevance of what is being searched for and the internet generally doesn't operate on common sense nor good taste. Sorry if anything it operates on popularity and porn.

Comments which degrade or insult groups are simply reported to web Administrators who may take such comments down. Admins are only as good as the users who read and report content.

Before making comment Greg upon the responsibilities of Administrators, you need to look at the big picture of what Administrators do

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Wednesday 23 May 2012

  • Min 9°C
  • Max 21°C

Thursday

  • 8 - 22°C

Friday

  • 7 - 22°C

Most Popular Articles


community digital epaper link

Latest Competitions



Win a share in $20,000 of Coles groceries Go>:


driveway comp

Fuel up with Driveway Go>:



Win a double pass to Bel Ami  Go>:


Win a romantic getaway for two at Fremantle's finest!  Go>:


Win a double pass to the Good Food & Wine show Go>:


Win tickets to FRAGILE  Go>:



Featured Video Clips


2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show promo



Community Newspaper Group Photographer Jon Hewson goes for a spin in a P/C-9A Hawk to help promote the 2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show, held on May 19 and 20. Video, images and editing by Jon Hewson.



Circus performer Brenna Day



Circus performer Brenna Day talks about her career and upcoming performances in the Perth International Burlesque Festival. Video, images and editing by Matthew Poon.


See more videos 

email subscribe linkHBF junior sports hero
Deliver our newspapers linkCommunityPix banner linkSolahart