Profit put ahead of people

02/Feb/2010

Comments: 2 readers have left a comment

I AM one of the 22 per cent of those in social housing in Ashfield that Garry Butler (Unfair burden, Eastern Reporter, January 19) wants to evict so house values may increase.

I moved to Ashfield 17 years ago and live independently even though I am confined to a wheelchair.

I have some questions for Mr Butler.

Am I on your list of people in social housing that should be moved?

Who is on your list and in what order or time frame is this reduction going to take place?

You say you are not against social housing per se, but by your actions you are against the 22 per cent who have made Ashfield home.

When you say you speak for the residents of West Ward I remind you that less than 16 per cent supported you with their vote at the recent council elections.

As to your claim about house values due to social housing, over the past 10 years values in Ashfield have risen at 12.5 per cent compared to the metro average of 11.3 per cent.

Your other claims about saturation creating social problems isn’t supported by facts from UWA’s crime research centre; in fact things are worse in Bassendean or Bayswater and other areas with less social housing.

Why don’t you declare that you are an estate agent?

Why do you think real people in real homes are a percentage?

Higher house values that you so desperately seek will only lead to more demand for social housing, so where is your argument?

It is profit before people if you are on Butler’s list.


Bookmark and Share

What everyone else is thinking

Sue Honeybrook

16/05/2010

Nicely put. What Housing NSW seems to be doing here is putting Social Housing tenants out of nice little homes that fit into the streetscape and community, as they should, and making huge profits on those sales. They are then using the RUDDY dollars to build shabby looking 'houso' blocks of units that in five years will look awful and not provide a true HOME www.raid.org.au believes in the societal need of social housing but is really annoyed at the 'throw them a bone' type of attitude in new social housing developments. Rudd and Keneally should be providing those who are disadvantaged and marginalized, a home, not a 'take it or leave it' box. I have stood by and watched the tears of my neighbours (social housing tenants) as they have been 'relocated' (which is a nice term for kicked out) to other areas after making their life and their children's life in a little part of suburbia with a bit of a garden and backyard. Well done. Nice little Federal/State Labor party collaboration.

Gerry Georgatos

11/03/2010

That's a brilliant piece of writing in terms of relevant and pertinent disclosures. Good on you.

Share your thoughts in 60 seconds!

Members : login to comment


 

Wednesday 23 May 2012

  • Min 9°C
  • Max 21°C

Thursday

  • 8 - 22°C

Friday

  • 7 - 22°C

Most Popular Articles


community digital epaper link

Latest Competitions



Win a share in $20,000 of Coles groceries Go>:


driveway comp

Fuel up with Driveway Go>:



Win a double pass to Bel Ami  Go>:


Win a romantic getaway for two at Fremantle's finest!  Go>:


Win a double pass to the Good Food & Wine show Go>:


Win tickets to FRAGILE  Go>:



Featured Video Clips


2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show promo



Community Newspaper Group Photographer Jon Hewson goes for a spin in a P/C-9A Hawk to help promote the 2012 RAAF Pearce Air Show, held on May 19 and 20. Video, images and editing by Jon Hewson.



Circus performer Brenna Day



Circus performer Brenna Day talks about her career and upcoming performances in the Perth International Burlesque Festival. Video, images and editing by Matthew Poon.


See more videos 

email subscribe linkHBF junior sports hero
Deliver our newspapers linkCommunityPix banner linkSolahart